Home‎ > ‎Competition‎ > ‎

Call for Judges

Call for Judges

If you would like to volunteer to be a competition judge, complete the electronic Judges Information Form  (click the link, complete and Submit) by Monday, November 5, 2018.   If you judged last year and filled out this form, just send us any updates/changes to your profile.

Training for all judges will be done by Carolyn Reynolds and a representative from STC International. Judge Training is mandatory for new judges.  

If you have questions about judging in the STC Regional Competition, please contact  our Chapter Representatives: Danielle Villegas (PMC);  Phoebe Forio (404.210.2053 - Atlanta); Carey Bates and Scott McCoy (551.427.7420 - New York), Cindy Pao and Erika Frensley (713.498.7618 -Houston);  Bobbi Werner (315.678.2052 - Rochester); Mike Nelson and Steve Jong (New England) and Regional Competition Chair:  Malu Schloss 917-312-1567. 

Why volunteer to be a judge? 

See the latest trends first-hand in technical communication, instructional design, promotional, informational and user support materials.  You are exposed to new ideas and a chance to discuss content development and design with professional peers. 

If you have good experience in technical writing, learning design, editing, or developing documentation or marketing communications, we're looking for you. If you are adept with technical illustrations, video editing, posters or packaging, you will be delighted at this opportunity to see great examples of work from others in the profession.

STC membership is not a requirement. We provide extensive training for judges. More experienced judges will serve as Team leaders and guide you through assessments.

Competition Schedule

 

October 15, 2018
Mon.

Call for Entries

·         Deadline for Entries - December 10, Friday, 6:00 pm

November 5, 2018, Monday.

 Deadline for Judges to sign up

December 7, 2018  Friday. 6:00 pm EDT

Deadline for Submission of Entries (both Print and Online)

November 13, Tues.

Training/Refresher for Judges and Training for Team Leaders.  By Carolyn Reynolds

Judge Teams are organized.

Dec. 4, Tues
Dec. 11, Tues
Dec 17, Monday

 

Practice Assessments – 2 or 3 sessions, Instructors - TBD

Mandatory for New judges

December 7, 2018, Friday

Deadline for submission of entries (online or hard-copy) by 6:00 PM, EDT

December 8, 2018, Saturday

Packing Day: Entries are organized. Online entries are added to the Judges secure site and print entries are mailed to Judge teams

December 17, 2018, Mon.

All Judge teams should have received their assigned entries and Login instructions for the Judges' website. 

Jan. 2-11, 2019 
(Milestone 1)

Milestone 1: Judges provide First Impressions to Team Leaders. Team Leaders provide first impressions to the Judging Co-Managers.

Jan. 14-26, 2019
(Milestone 2)

Milestone 2: Judges provide draft Assessment 1 to Team leader for at least one entry. Team leader provides draft comments for at least one entry to Judging Co-Managers.

Jan. 28-Feb. 8, 2019
(Milestone 3)

Milestone 3: Judges provide feedback on draft Assessment 2 to Team Leader. Team Leader provides draft comments to Judging Co-Managers.

Feb. 11-Feb. 22, 2019
(Milestone 4)

Milestone 4: Judges complete draft Assessment 3 and by now should have completed all 3 assessments. Team Leader sends drafts to Judging Co-Managers.           

February 25- March 8 , 2019
(Milestone 5)

Milestone 5: Judges finish assessment sheets and collaborate on writing an Overview for each assigned entry. Team meets to decide if the entry deserves an award and at what level. The team may decide to recommend the entry for Best of Show and prepare for it. 

March 9, 2019 Saturday
Consensus Day

Consensus Day: Final judging. (Locations: NY, Philadelphia, Atlanta, Houston, Rochester and virtually)

  • All written comments for all entries are refined and given to Team Leaders and turned over to Judging Co-Managers.
  • Teams determine recommendations for awards, including Best of Show. 
  • Group discussion and presentation of winning entries
  • March 12 – If there was no time to decide a Best of Show was not decided on Consensus day, March 9, we will organize a separate meeting and an appoint a Sub-committee.

April 15, 2019

Regional Best of Show, Distinguished, Excellence and Merit awardees announced. 

May 5-8, 2019

STC International Summit in Denver, CO.

TBD

Virtual TechComm Roadshow
 STC Joint TechComm Roadshow Event with other chapter competitions

 

What does a Competition Judge do?

Judges are responsible for evaluating every entry they receive. They must provide feedback to each entrant. The assessment should provide clear, impartial, and constructive feedback. Judge duties include:

  • Check the contents of the package as soon as possible after receiving it to ensure that everything assigned is included.
  • Review each entry. Provide constructive feedback on each entry.
  • Meet with team members for consensus on awards. Contribute to writing any Best of Show recommendations.
  • Complete and return assessment forms by the specified method and date.

Judges are grouped into teams of three including a Team Leader.

The Team Leader is usually someone with previous experience as a local/regional or international judge and/or someone with a wide degree of technical communication experience. The Team leader also has  a few additional responsibilities to make the judging run smoothly:

  • Ensure that all team members have the same entries and that all entries are complete (that is, all submission forms are present and properly filled out), compliant with competition rules (for example, produced during the correct time window), and placed in the appropriate competition category. 
  • Monitor the team’s progress vs. the scheduled Milestones
  • Answer team members’ questions about the entries and the judging process. The team leader is the liaison between the team and the competition managers to resolve problems.
  • Make sure all team members have completed all their assigned entry assessments by consensus judging day. 
  • Team leaders should check with their team members regularly throughout the evaluation period. Lead the consensus meeting and make sure entries and assessment forms are correct, professional, acceptable thorough, and delivered to the judging co-managers on time.
  • Schedule team meetings as necessary. 
  • In the consensus meeting, communicate award levels and any Best of Show recommendation to the Judging co-managers

How much time will it take?

Judge Training normally takes 1.5 - 2 hours and is conducted over the web. Each judge is assigned an average of  3 entries and judges follow a schedule of milestones culminating in Consensus Day.  We estimate that judges will devote a minimum of 15-24 hours for judging. Most meetings between team members can be done over the phone or web.

Criteria for evaluation depend on the entry category. Here are some examples:
  • User Support materials - For online help, is it easy to find the information you need and are topics explained thoroughly?
  • Instructional materials - Is the eLearning / mlearning compelling and does it enable the audience to complete learning objectives?
  • Promotional materials - Do the marketing brochures and web materials excite you about the products or processes described?
  • Informational materials - Is the website a good example of content strategy and make you want to view more pages?  Can you find what you want quickly?

The answer to the above questions and more may convince you and your team members that an entry is worthy of awards: Distinguished, Excellence or Merit. You might even recommend the entry for the Best of Show award!

On Consensus Day, all judges converge for the final judging and selection of Best of Show, (usually 4 hours with lunch). We meet in live locations (NY, Philadelphia, Atlanta, Houston and Rochester) and provide virtual access to those who cannot be present for the activity.


Comments